Interobserver Variability in Diagnosing High-Grade Neuroendocrine Carcinoma of the Lung and Comparing It with the Morphometric Analysis
ÇϽ¿¬, ÇÑÁ¤È£, ±è¿Ï¼·, ¼º´¼º, ³ë¹Ì¼÷,
¼Ò¼Ó »ó¼¼Á¤º¸
ÇϽ¿¬ ( Ha Seung-Yeon )
Gachon University Gil Hospital Department of Pathology
ÇÑÁ¤È£ ( Han Joung-Ho )
Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine Department of Pathology
±è¿Ï¼· ( Kim Wan-Seop )
Konkuk University College of Medicine Department of Pathology
¼º´¼º ( Suh Byung-Seong )
Sungkyunkwan University Kangbuk Samsung Hospital Department of Occupational Medicine
³ë¹Ì¼÷ ( Roh Mee-Sook )
Dong-A University College of Medicine Department of Pathology
KMID : 0357920120460010042
Abstract
Background: Distinguishing small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) and large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma (LCNEC) of the lung is difficult with little information about interobserver variability.
Methods: One hundred twenty-nine cases of resected SCLC and LCNEC were independently evaluated by four pathologists and classified according to the 2004 World Health Organization criteria. Agreement was regarded as ¡°unanimous¡± if all four pathologists agreed on the classification. The kappa statistic was calculated to measure the degree of agreement between pathologists. We also measured cell size using image analysis, and receiver-operating-characteristic curve analysis was performed to evaluate cell size in predicting the diagnosis of high-grade neuroendocrine (NE) carcinomas in 66 cases.
Results: Unanimous agreement was achieved in 55.0% of 129 cases. The kappa values ranged from 0.35 to 0.81. Morphometric analysis reaffirmed that there was a continuous spectrum of cell size from SCLC to LCNEC and showed that tumors with cells falling in the middle size range were difficult to categorize and lacked unanimous agreement.
Conclusions: Our results provide an objective explanation for considerable interobserver variability in the diagnosis of high-grade pulmonary NE carcinomas. Further studies would need to define more stringent and objective definitions of cytologic and architectural characteristics to reliably distinguish between SCLC and LCNEC.
Å°¿öµå
Lung; Small cell lung carcinoma; Large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma; Observer variation; Image analysis
¿ø¹® ¹× ¸µÅ©¾Æ¿ô Á¤º¸
µîÀçÀú³Î Á¤º¸